MUI Wags the Dog’s Tail Once Again!

In: Uncategorized

11 Feb 2009

Apa Kata Dunia?

I have to hand it to the Majelis Ulama Indonesia aka the Indonesian Ulema Council – these guys really know how to make Indonesians sound even more stupid than we already have. First, they made a fuss about Yoga and decided to ban the sport since it had the “Om” chanting which they said, referred to the religious ritual of the Hindus. And then they changed their mind. And then they were revising the ban and decided to go ahead with it. The irony of this whole thing was that almost none of Yoga practitioners in Indonesia actually ever chanted anything during their Yoga activities. I don’t doubt it, since it would be very hard trying to maintain a Matsyasana position while breathing in and out with rythym and trying to go “Ommm..” with any breath that is left from your lungs.

Not satisfied with to-ban-or-not-to-ban Yoga (and also perhaps running low with bribery income), the MUI decided to produce an edict against smoking. Personally, I don’t care much about this fatwa as I am a non-smoker and I also think that the chance of making the people in this country to stop smoking is probably the same as trying to make Bakrie fix the Sidoarjo mud disaster. Not gonna happen.

But this topic caught my interest when it was being discussed on MetroTV’s Today’s Dialogue titled (quite creatively so) Obral Fatwa MUI, which means – roughly translated – The MUI Fatwa Sale. You can watch the whole show here.

Mr. Amidhan from MUI seemed to be so sure and confident that there were, apparently, a lot of people who demanded that smoking was to be an edict. He said, “Oh, we had plenty of requests from people, personal or from organisations, etc., asking for this edict to be made, sure, of course.”

And yet … he didn’t produce any evidence at all. No letters or petitions signed by people saying so. So how could he say those things when he had no actual proof whatsoever? Not good enough, wrinkly old man. I want proofs. Until  I actually see hard copied evidence of signatures from a bunch of hypocritical non-smokers who are actually looking for some charity fund from the tobacco companies, I won’t believe a single world that you say.

For me this just another classic case of ‘Instead of solving the problem, let’s just forbid people to do something and hope for the best!’, rather than ‘Let’s educate the people that smoking is unhealthy and even if they do smoke, let’s advise them to do it in the proper places.’

But I guess for me, the smoking edict was not as bad of a joke as it was for the edict to forbid people to abstain in this year`s general elections. This, I thought, had got to be a fucking joke.

I’d love to tell this wrinkly old man that it is my right to go abstain when I feel like it, because as far as I know, all the politicians in this country can only offer lies and deceit, and I won’t trust the fate of this country to those low-life scumbags ever.

I seriously think MUI must’ve thought Indonesian people are stupid or something.

As if we don’t know that those political campaigns either on television or billboards are all shite. As if we don’t know that they only bring up the poor and uneducated people at times like these but once they get elected, they’d be too busy exchanging bribes and dirty money to each other to even give a shit about the future of this country. As if we are too gullible to believe the empty promises those corrupt politicians say – how they’re gonna give 20% of the budget for educational purpose.  Golkar has actually done this in their telly ads and it’s kind of stupid because that is really nothing new – 20% has always been the budget and it’s stated in the 1945 Constitutions since, like, forever. So by bringing that up and claiming that they’re the ones who’d made all that possible, is equal to them visiting hookers and catching gonorrhea and go around saying that they’ve cured AIDS.

And the bits where these politicians always act as if they’re gods and appear as if they’re the ones who’re going to save this wretched country from it’s terrible fate – sickening or what? Fuck off, assholes, you’re the ones who make this country impossible to live in. It’s people like you, who made poverty, uneducated people, flood victims, and everything bad about this country, exist.

So is it really my fault for abstaining? Is it really? Because I seriously think by voting or not, it won’t make a damn difference. Not with the kind of law and justice system this country is running. No, not really.

*)Image of Suster Ngesot is courtesy of Golput.wordpress.com

26 Responses to MUI Wags the Dog’s Tail Once Again!

Avatar

the writer

February 11th, 2009 at 3:31 am

I certainly don’t mind to gloat over other people miseries but things like these make me exhale a sigh of relief that I’m thousands miles away from home and need not to worry about the wackiness of some of the citizens

Wacky? Try ‘maruk’ :P

Avatar

the writer

February 11th, 2009 at 4:37 am

whoops. I wrote it all wrong LOL I meant “I certainly don’t mean”

Sorry folks. It’s not “mind” but “mean” (doh)

Avatar

Chris Taylor

February 11th, 2009 at 6:15 am

does my yoga mat mean I’m an infidel? :)

Yes, yes it does. Burn it!!! :P

Avatar

boy

February 11th, 2009 at 7:53 am

When I do Yoga, I always chant “Oww”,”Auch”,”aduh…” instead of “Om”…

I bet the council members never do Yoga before hehe…

I don’t think they have, Boy. Not with fat stomachs they can’t. Too fat and full of cholesterol everywhere, you see :)

Avatar

jensen99

February 11th, 2009 at 2:56 pm

Yeah, freaky method to regulates people by installing afterlife punishment plug-in on any non-religious business. :mrgreen:

*look at the suster ngesot pic*

I guess someday they will ban horror movie too… :cool:

I don’t know about horror movies… I mean look at the sinetrons, they’re shite and they’re everywhere, poisoning the minds of our fellow Indonesians! LOL.

I wonder why is there no edict against corruption? That makes a whole lot more sense to me!

Avatar

Devi Girsang

February 11th, 2009 at 4:53 pm

LOL nice pic (even though I’m not sure if I get the original message from it)!

I’m non-smoker too, so if they can make our beloved country free from indoor smoking I’ll appreciate it very much. If they wish our Indonesian people to be as smart as Jewish, they should really learn and practice harder. (I’ve just read the secrets why Jewish people are so damn smart from Elyani’s blog)

Dev!!! Don’t say the J word! You know how much people hate them! Those ‘Zionist-haters’ will come and start throwing abusive comments at us if we as much as mention the J word! LOL :P

Avatar

wiwin

February 11th, 2009 at 6:31 pm

ntar malem mao yoga ni ther, nga ada tuh make2 istilah Om.. @_@ *lega* LOL

Ya, jangan yah, nanti tau2 didatengin sama pak Amidhan dan disuruh bertobat gimana? :D

Avatar

tere616

February 12th, 2009 at 12:38 pm

OMG, even when I learned meditation from my Hindu teacher, she didn’t teach me that Om or Am. The spell is no relation with the religion. It’s like a tools so we can concentrate more and more.

And same like boy, during my Yoga practice, even my teacher laugh at me because of my “Holly Shut” or “Ouch” chant.

That Yoga things because MUI didn’t want to loose their “pamor” with their relative in Malaysia.

That’s what I thought too, Tere. I think the MUI was feeling left out by the Malaysians Ulema because they weren’t productive enough – in terms of making edicts etc., which is stupid since none of those edicts actually make a huge difference. Fat chance telling a smoke addict to stop smoking just because he/she is going to hell. They’d just shrug and go, “So?”

Avatar

Rob

February 12th, 2009 at 4:47 pm

This is what you get when you put a group of people together with nothing better to do. You call yourselves the MUI and then write fatwas that serve as humorous talking points, and get people wondering “are these people for real or what?”

Maybe the problem with Yoga is the MUI misunderstands that women (and men) in all manner of contortionist poses (and tight clothes) and chanting Om is not sexual and that no “Om” is there watching these poses…

If you get what I mean.

If they in fact turned out to be misinterpreting Yoga that way, I wouldn’t have been surprised at all. They’ve never been the brightest stars in the sky after all, judging by the edicts they made.

Avatar

Diny

February 12th, 2009 at 9:58 pm

@boy: same here! i’d either curse or huffin and puffin when doing yoga. forget ‘om’!
seriously, mui can’t really tell people what to do with their silly ‘fatwa’. especially for non muslim, it’s not fair for them not to be able to do things because mui said so.
besides, mui can just ‘obral’ their fatwas to their own people; instead of making it a law for everybody, mui can tell the islam population that they won’t go to heaven and be with the virgins if they smoke or chant ‘om’ during yoga.

And no one will actually give a shit. LOL. Edict or no edict, smokers will still smoke as long as they still have the money (and lungs) for it. It’s a classic Indonesian government’s style to solve problems the idiot way – instead of solving it, they just ban and forbid things. They probably haven’t learnt from their teenage children that the more you forbid people, the more they want to break the rules!

Avatar

Devi Girsang

February 12th, 2009 at 11:37 pm

OOPS.. Sorry about that! :D Can you edit my previous comment?

LOL Relax Dev, I was kidding. It’s just that the majority of Indonesians seem to loathe Jewish people so much they will always fling the Zionist word in every chance they get :D

Avatar

cn

February 12th, 2009 at 11:50 pm

i heard they’re banning jaipong?? because of their sexy costumes? really????? *haven’t read the paper for a while*

Not banning but restricting it to contain less erotic moves. Whatever the fuck that means. We have never had problems with Jaipong for hundreds of years and now it’s considered to be pornographic?

Avatar

Ivy

February 13th, 2009 at 12:12 am

The only time I see ‘Om’ being used in Yoga was when I watched “Snow Buddies” and it was the dog chanting that word….

ROFL… maybe those Ulemas knew the “Om” bit after watching the movie and started freaking out thinking all Yoga practitioners do that! What a joke…

Avatar

rima fauzi

February 13th, 2009 at 6:49 am

First, I’ve been busy like hell this week what with meetings, first week of school, recording sessions and preparing for a gig tomorrow night. Sorry if Í’ve been neglecting you and your blog.
second, i need time to get used to this template of yours, but i know how you love blue and i know u’re gonna stick with this one for at least a few weeks before changing it back or to some other template.
third, I’m glad I dont live in Indo at the moment as I am thinking of taking up yoga, smoking, not wanting to participate in the upcoming elections, etc etc.. I’m as dirty an infidel as they come.. lol
Fourth, why can’t I scroll down and see my own comment? I had to cut and paste this comment to word and then copy paste it to ur blog to be able to write this long comment (which isn’t really long anyway).

Hey Rima, welcome back!! Haven’t talked to you for aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaages.
Yeah I tested the comment box, it didn’t seem to be able to view comments any longer than 5-7 rows long, although it is possible to write a longer one.

Himself is going to make a custom blog template for me so expect something brill in the future – this template is just temporary. The old one, the white one, is kinda fucked up for some unknown reason (the whole 404 page not found thingy, which I’ve told you last week, still don’t know how it happened!

Avatar

mochachocolatarita

February 13th, 2009 at 10:55 am

rules are made to be broken…or wrongly interpreted

- ban premarital sex > demand your gf to be a virgin and feel free to visit whorehouses
- ban yoga > people might really start saying “om” later…oh, how about saying “fuck”?
- ban bikini > let’s swim or parade in the nude
- ban sexy dance moves on tv > goyang on the streets yuk, hiuk…and the rulemaker said “let’s organize an orgy after writing this ban”

ban something, and it will only get even more popular. LOL

I know, it amazes me how stupid certain people can get. By fussing so much over something that they dislike, they will only attract more attention to it. For example, when that Fitna movie was out, MUI was also making a big deal and as the result more people actually wanted to see what was in the movie out of curiosity! LOL.

Avatar

Denny D' Little

February 13th, 2009 at 3:46 pm

Fakta tentang MUI:
- bukan lembaga pemerintah, tapi dibiayai oleh pemerintah. (salah satu sumber pendapatan pemerintah adalah cukai rokok).
- MUI sebaiknya dibubarkan saja, karena pajak pendapatan saya dipakai pemerintah untuk membiayai mereka juga.
- karena bukan lembaga pemerintah, sertifikat halalnya tidak mengikat secara hukum. (sertifikat lebih cocok dikeluarkan oleh kerjasama depag dan bppom).
- MUI termasuk dalam daftar lembaga korup dalam survey LSI (eksternal audit katanya tidak pernah dilakukan).

Anda benar, Denny, oleh karena itu saya tidak mengerti kenapa lembaga ini masih tetap berdiri sampai sekarang karena status dan fungsinyanya sudah tidak jelas – mereka hanya menang di umur saja karena sudah berdiri sedemikian lamanya (dari jaman Soeharto). Tapi berdasarkan Today’s Dialogue ‘MUI Obral Fatwa’ yang saya berikan link-nya diatas, MUI tetap ngotot kalau mereka itu bersih dan sering diaudit, tapi ya itu… nggak jelas yang ngaudit siapa, hasilnya mana, bersih apa tidaknya, semua cuma omdo alias omong doang!

Avatar

Elyani

February 14th, 2009 at 4:23 pm

Kalau MUI boleh mengharamkan ini itu mungkin tidak ada salahnya kita juga boleh menhgharamkan MUI. Bunyinya saja sudah gak enak..MUI..nafik :)

Setubuh!! Eh…setujuuu! Asal muasalnya juga udah nggak jelas, mestinya dibubarin ajah..

Avatar

Finally Woken

February 15th, 2009 at 2:39 pm

I’m not surprised that the ban was due to a bad experience of one of the MUI members. Maybe he heard some place called “Ooommmm” and he thought he was called. So he went in, looked around and saw a bunch of women in tight customs and compromising positions. He thought he’d died and gone to heaven.

Only to realise that he wasn’t welcome there.

I won’t be surprised if they were that gullible. LOL. Maybe the rejection still stung, that’s why the ban was out as a way of revenge…

Avatar

Ecky

February 15th, 2009 at 6:20 pm

Just curious, they banned those thing but they allowed old prick to marry under age girl? How funny!

Btw, did you hear that the movie called Perempuan Berkalung Sorban will be withdraw from the cinema because of MUI? Just because the antagonist character is a kyai/ustad and they said the movie gives the kyais bad name, d’oh

This is what happens when people start to involve religious issues with art – in other countries there might not be a problem but in Indo, it’ll just create unnecessary problems. MUI didn’t have the right to ban anything in the first place, and I’d bet my ass they haven’t even actually seen the movie yet! I think Hanung Bramantyo must thank these guys because they’re doing the publicity job for his movie, unintentionally…

Avatar

bud

February 19th, 2009 at 11:41 pm

hidup golput!!ntar nerakanya penuh dong..

Gak apa2, enak lagi bisa sembari barbeque… :D

Avatar

boneman

February 20th, 2009 at 3:42 am

strangely, I stand on an odd bit of corner, and, as the paint dries, find myself wondering about it.

I first started snitching smokes from my Old Man’s cigar box and Ma’s purse back in 1957.
Finally, with the help of a friend, quit cold turkey (now I only eat hot turkey? No, as in, no patches, gum, fake cigarettes)(well, I’ll get back to that last one) in 2002.
WOW! I can run with the dogs. Heck, now that they’re older, I can actually run FASTER!
BUT….
I do use two things, still.
I use my friends that still smoke for patches.
Yeah….I stand close to them and sniff the second hand smoke.
Still haven’t taken a hit, yet. Hope i don’t.

IF things get to where I want a smoke really really bad?
Clover flowers work.
Catnip, too, if you don’t mind menthol.
So, to erradicate tobacco, we’re also talking about erradicating all sorts of smokable items.
HA! Good luck with THAT! When I burn shrubs and weeds? I stand on the smoke side of the fire.
I’m not saying folks should smoke. I’m thinking that some smokers can’t control their smoke intake (like me) and become addicted to it. THEY should quit.

Now, about the yoga.
Dang, I went from a 42 waist size (if i was lucky…more like 44) back to a 38 over the course of one Summer of Yoga.
Never did use the “om” that I hear about.
Just the exercise, standing better, that’s all.

Can you imagine making the word “om” illegal?

ommmmmmm

(no)

ommmmmmmm

Now, even though that was windy

Glad to hear yoga made a difference to your waistline!

It’s a great form of exercise, and it’s good for health, there’s no chanting involved and it gets you all nice and stretchy – so why ban it? I have no clue either. There are more important things to ban, don’t you think? Name five things; corruption, bribing, lying (ha! let’s see how those politicans can get away from this one), giving out empty promises (think Bakrie) and marrying underage children (think Syekh Puji).

Unfortunately, those five random things don’t seem that important to MUI. Nooo…smoking and yoga, on the other hand, can ruin and threaten the stability of this country!!!!

Avatar

Beijinger

February 21st, 2009 at 11:28 am

About yoga ,is it helpful to quit smoking?

Avatar

pjbali

February 21st, 2009 at 1:58 pm

Pesonally my favorite fatwa was the breastfeeding fatwa that came out of al azhar a few years back. One could always hope that the MUI could fatwa themselves into irrelevance but I think they lack the imagination.

Hmm…nah, they’re not that smart. :D

Avatar

Hainan

February 25th, 2009 at 5:28 pm

Hi!
Great post.
I think every position should put some special smoking sections for separating from the non-smoker.FOrbidding somking for the sake of our wealty well-being.

Good point. The government should do that. Some public places already install such spaces and most people are willing to go for it so why the edict?

Avatar

sophia

March 6th, 2009 at 11:11 am

I’ have never been to smoking, smoking is hurt body health . I think every position should put some special smoking sections for separating from the non-smoker

Avatar

mare

March 11th, 2009 at 9:52 am

I’m a balinese hindu myself
and sadly I never do yoga
is it good ?

OM certainly is a holy word for us
it’s as sacred as word YHWH for jewish

and I am sorry to hear that yoga is forbidden for moslems
but rest assure that yoga is not a way to spreads hindu
because hindu itself is not an expansive religion.
It’s takes a lot of ceremony and offerings to convert someone to hindu, saying some word wouldn’t make you a hindu.

Do tell that to the bastards at MUI and they will give a 100 reasons why you’re wrong. And your Hindu. And they’re not. And they still think they know more than you do. Absurd, no?

Comment Form

About this blog

Therrysays.com is a personal blog where I share my thoughts, opinions and rants about life in Indonesia and beyond. If this all sounds good to you, enjoy your stay, but if it isn't your cuppa tea, then kindly leave and let me be! Cheers.

  • Eru: Naah, I don't do 'Whaaat?' :D Ayana? is that the one in southern part of Bali? the one with the [...]
  • therry: @Cn: From what I gather you've found someone rather special yourself *wink2* @Finally Woken: I ha [...]
  • therry: @PJ: Thank you! Do come to my wedding if you can make it :) Yes, the whole coffee ritual is kind of [...]
  • John: Congratulations!! :) pls post up some pix! [...]
  • Mia: Looking forward to seeing you soon! You, Yefta and Tony MUST come to our house to meet our four ador [...]

 

February 2009
M T W T F S S
« Jan   Mar »
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
232425262728  

MyBlogLog

Adopt a Puppy!

Photobucket

I am on Globalpost.com!

Image and video hosting by TinyPic

Copyrights & Hits

Blog Archives

StatPress

Visits today: 83